top of page

ADS Spirits Pvt. Ltd. v. The Registrar of Trade Marks

Oct 17
2 min read

A trademark cannot be refused merely because it is not “unique”; the statutory question is whether it is capable of distinguishing the relevant goods or services.


Short Description About the Case


This appeal concerned the registrability of the word mark “OFFER” for alcoholic beverages, except beers, and alcoholic preparations for making beverages in Class 33. The dispute focused on the correct test for assessing distinctiveness under Section 9(1)(a) of the Trade Marks Act, 1999.


Facts


ADS Spirits Pvt. Ltd. sought registration of the mark “OFFER” in Class 33. The Trade Marks Registry raised an objection under Section 9(1)(a), stating that the mark was not capable of distinguishing the applicant’s goods from those of others. In earlier proceedings, the Single Judge found that the examination had applied an incorrect test by focusing on whether the mark was “unique”, rather than assessing its distinctiveness in relation to the specified goods. The Registrar was directed to reconsider the application within four months. ADS Spirits appealed, contending that the Court should instead direct the application to proceed to publication under Section 20 of the Act and Rule 39 of the Trade Marks Rules, 2017.


Findings


The Division Bench found no legal or factual error requiring interference with the Single Judge’s decision to remand the application for reconsideration. It recognised the importance of applying the statutory test of distinctiveness, rather than imposing a separate requirement that a mark must be “unique”. The Court also considered that the registration authority was better placed to assess the application at the initial registration stage under the prescribed statutory process. The decision did not itself grant registration of “OFFER”.


Suggestion


When responding to a Section 9(1)(a) objection, address whether the mark is capable of distinguishing the applicant’s goods or services in the relevant commercial context. Avoid relying only on the claim that a mark is original or unique. The applicant should explain the mark’s meaning, its relationship to the goods, and any supporting evidence of acquired distinctiveness where legally relevant. A remand for fresh examination should not be described as a registration or final acceptance.


Judgment / Principle


The Division Bench dismissed ADS Spirits’ appeal on 15 September 2026. The direction for fresh consideration remained in place, requiring the Registrar to assess the mark under the correct Section 9(1)(a) test within the time specified by the earlier order. The key principle is that distinctiveness—not abstract uniqueness—is the statutory criterion at issue.

bottom of page