top of page

MHG IP Holding Singapore Pte. Ltd. & Ors. v. Evergreen Dealcom Pvt. Ltd. & Ors.

Oct 31
2 min read

Using a reputed hospitality trademark for allied real-estate services can amount to infringement where it suggests an association with the trademark owner.


Short Description About the Case


This case concerned the “ANANTARA” trademark, associated with the plaintiffs’ hospitality and resort business, and the defendants’ use of the same or similar mark for real-estate and allied services. The Delhi High Court considered whether the plaintiffs were entitled to summary judgment and permanent protection against the defendants’ use.


Facts


The plaintiffs, entities associated with Minor Hotel Group, relied on their registered rights and goodwill in “ANANTARA” for hotels, resorts, real-estate and related services. They alleged that the defendants used “ANANTARA” or similar marks for real-estate projects and related promotional activities, creating an impression of a connection or affiliation with the plaintiffs. The plaintiffs sought permanent injunctive relief against the challenged use, including online identifiers and promotional material.


Findings


The Court held that the defendants had no real prospect of successfully defending the claim and granted summary judgment. It permanently restrained them from using “ANANTARA” or any identical or deceptively similar mark, including the identified project names, for real-estate, hospitality, residential or allied services.


The injunction also covered online identifiers and promotional use that could suggest an association or affiliation with the plaintiffs. The plaintiffs did not press their claims for damages and costs.


Suggestion


Owners of established hospitality and lifestyle brands should monitor the use of their marks in related sectors, including residential developments, branded residences, real-estate projects and online promotional channels. When seeking summary judgment, a plaintiff should present clear evidence of trademark rights, the defendant’s challenged use, the relationship between the relevant services and the likelihood of confusion or implied affiliation.


Judgment / Principle


The Delhi High Court granted summary judgment and permanently restrained the defendants from using the “ANANTARA” mark or deceptively similar marks for the relevant services. The case illustrates that trademark protection may extend beyond a brand owner’s immediate service category when the competing use is likely to suggest an unauthorised commercial association.

bottom of page