Niva Bupa Health Insurance Company Limited & Anr. v. Mr. Vishal Rattewal & Ors.
Merely referring to a company’s trademark in critical social-media posts does not automatically amount to trademark infringement.
Short Description About the Case
This case concerned a commercial suit arising from critical social-media content referring to Niva Bupa Health Insurance Company. The Delhi High Court considered whether the alleged use of the company’s trademark in such posts constituted infringement in the course of trade and whether the dispute was properly maintainable before its Intellectual Property Division.
Facts
Niva Bupa Health Insurance Company Limited and another plaintiff initiated proceedings against Vishal Rattewal and others concerning social-media posts that referred to the company and criticised it. The plaintiffs sought to pursue the matter as a trademark dispute. The Court examined whether the challenged references amounted to use of the mark in the course of trade within the meaning of Section 29 of the Trade Marks Act, 1999.
Findings
The Court held that referring to a company’s trademark in critical social-media posts did not, by itself, amount to trademark use in the course of trade under Section 29. The Court concluded that the dispute, as presented, did not concern infringement of intellectual property rights and was therefore not maintainable before the Intellectual Property Division.
The decision is important because it distinguishes commercial use of a trademark from references to a brand made in the context of criticism. It should not be read as a blanket immunity for all social-media content: the nature, context and purpose of the use remain relevant.
Suggestion
Before filing a trademark suit over online content, an IP owner should identify the specific commercial use alleged to infringe the mark and explain how the statutory infringement test is satisfied. Critical references, reviews and commentary should be assessed carefully before being characterised as trademark infringement. Where a dispute is essentially about reputation or allegedly false statements, the appropriate legal cause of action and forum should be evaluated separately.
Judgment / Principle
The Delhi High Court held that the dispute was not maintainable before its Intellectual Property Division because the pleaded conduct did not establish trademark infringement in the course of trade. The key lesson is that not every mention of a registered mark constitutes infringement under Section 29.



