top of page

ITC Limited & Anr. v. Umesh Arora & Anr.

Oct 31
2 min read

A trademark registration may be vulnerable to cancellation where the proprietor does not defend the challenge and the mark is no longer being used.


Short Description About the Case


This case concerned ITC Limited and ITC Hotels Limited’s challenge to the registration of the device mark “THE BREW BUKHARA”. The plaintiffs alleged that the mark was deceptively similar to their established “BUKHARA” trademark.


Facts


ITC Limited and ITC Hotels Limited approached the Delhi High Court seeking cancellation of the registration of “THE BREW BUKHARA”. They relied on their established rights in the “BUKHARA” mark and alleged that the registered mark was deceptively similar. The registered proprietor did not file a reply to the rectification proceedings, and the Court was informed through the trademark agent that use of the challenged mark had been discontinued.


Findings


The Court considered the challenge in the context of the registered proprietor’s failure to file a reply and the information that the mark was no longer in use. The registration was cancelled. The decision demonstrates the importance of actively defending rectification proceedings and maintaining a consistent position regarding the use of a registered trademark.


Because the proprietor did not contest the challenge, the decision should not be overstated as a fully contested determination of every issue concerning similarity, reputation or use.


Suggestion


Trademark proprietors should respond within the prescribed time to rectification petitions and preserve evidence of actual commercial use, reputation and the basis for registration. If a mark has been discontinued, the proprietor should obtain legal advice before making statements about non-use or abandoning its defence. Brand owners seeking cancellation should submit registration records, evidence of reputation and a clear explanation of the grounds for rectification.


Judgment / Principle


The Delhi High Court cancelled the registration of the “THE BREW BUKHARA” device mark. The case highlights the importance of responding to rectification proceedings and the potential consequences of leaving a challenge undefended, particularly when the proprietor has reportedly stopped using the mark.

bottom of page