top of page

Mankind Consumer Products Private Limited v. Alaina Healthcare Private Limited & Anr.

Oct 31
2 min read

Descriptive elements in a competing product name do not automatically prevent infringement of an established trademark.


Short Description About the Case


The dispute concerned Mankind Consumer Products’ registered trademark “ACNESTAR” and the defendants’ use of “ACNE SCAR”, “ACNE+SCAR” and similar variants for pharmaceutical, medicinal, skincare and related goods. The Delhi High Court considered whether the competing names were deceptively similar despite their descriptive elements and the use of another house mark.


Facts


The plaintiff relied on its registered word mark “ACNESTAR”, registered in Class 5 from 25 April 2005, and an assignment in its favour dated 19 February 2025. It alleged that the defendants’ product names were deceptively similar and were being used for overlapping or allied goods. The plaintiff sought interim protection against continued manufacture, advertising, sale and supply under the challenged names.


Findings


The Court found a prima facie case of trademark infringement. It did not accept that the inclusion of descriptive wording relating to acne and scars, or the presence of an additional house mark, necessarily removed the risk of confusion with “ACNESTAR”. It restrained the defendants from dealing in pharmaceutical, medicinal, skincare or allied goods under “ACNE SCAR”, “ACNE+SCAR”, “ACNESCAR” or any deceptively similar mark.


The Court also allowed the defendant a two-month period to recall existing stock and withdraw listings. That period did not permit further manufacture, advertising, offering for sale or supply under the challenged mark. The Court expressly clarified that its findings were prima facie and would not determine the final merits at trial.


Suggestion


Pharmaceutical and skincare businesses should conduct trademark clearance searches before adopting product names, including names combining descriptive words with distinctive elements. Existing registration certificates, assignment documents, product labels, invoices, sales records and examples of the competing use should be preserved. A response to an infringement allegation should assess the overall similarity, the goods involved and the likely perception of the relevant consumers.


Judgment / Principle


The Delhi High Court allowed the plaintiff’s interim application and restrained the defendants from using the challenged names or deceptively similar marks for the relevant goods pending final adjudication. The order illustrates that descriptive elements do not necessarily avoid infringement where the overall mark remains deceptively similar. It remains an interim finding, not a final decree after trial.

bottom of page