top of page

Jitendrabhai Mohanbhai Kriplani v. State of Gujarat

Oct 17
3 min read

Counterfeit goods bearing a trademark do not automatically constitute copyright infringement; criminal enforcement must respect the distinct statutory requirements of copyright law and trademark law.


SHORT DESCRIPTION ABOUT THE CASE:


This case concerned criminal proceedings arising from allegations that shops were selling counterfeit Apple-branded mobile accessories. The complainant invoked copyright-related offences in connection with the allegedly counterfeit products, packaging and labels. The Gujarat High Court examined whether ordinary commercial hardware and functional labels could be treated as copyright-protected works and whether the police raid and seizure complied with the safeguards under the Trade Marks Act, 1999. The Court ultimately quashed the FIR and consequential proceedings against the petitioner.


FACTS:


The proceedings arose from an FIR registered in October 2022 at Kalupur Police Station, Ahmedabad, concerning the alleged sale of counterfeit Apple products and mobile accessories. The complaint alleged that certain shops were selling duplicate products, including mobile accessories and related items bearing Apple’s trademarks.


The complainant was associated with Griffin Intellectual Property Services Pvt. Ltd., which claimed authority from Apple Inc. to investigate and take action against counterfeit products. Following preliminary inquiries, a raid was conducted at the shops, and various items were allegedly found and seized.


The petitioner challenged the FIR under Section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, seeking quashing of proceedings under Sections 51, 63 and 64 of the Copyright Act, 1957.

The petitioner argued that commercial hardware such as cables, chargers and mobile accessories did not themselves constitute copyrightable artistic or literary works. It was further argued that the allegations essentially concerned trademark falsification and that the mandatory procedural safeguards governing searches and seizures under the Trade Marks Act had not been followed.


FINDINGS:


The Gujarat High Court distinguished copyright infringement from trademark falsification. It observed that copyright protection under the Copyright Act is confined to legally recognised categories of original works, including literary and artistic works, rather than extending automatically to ordinary commercial products merely because they carry a brand name or label.

The Court held that commercial hardware, including chargers, cables and electronic accessories, cannot simply be treated as artistic or literary works for the purpose of sustaining a prosecution under Section 63 of the Copyright Act. A prosecution based on copyright infringement must identify the relevant copyrightable work and establish how the alleged conduct infringes the rights protected by the statute.


The Court also examined the alternative argument that the conduct could be prosecuted under Sections 103 and 104 of the Trade Marks Act. It found that the statutory safeguards under Section 115(4) had not been complied with, including the requirements relating to the appropriate officer and the Registrar’s opinion before the relevant search and seizure.


The Court rejected the attempt to use copyright provisions to bypass the safeguards prescribed by trademark legislation. It concluded that continuing the criminal proceedings in the circumstances would amount to an abuse of the process of law.


SUGGESTION:


This judgment is useful when advising clients in counterfeit-goods matters where trademark and copyright allegations are being combined.


Before initiating criminal proceedings, the rights holder should identify the specific intellectual-property right allegedly infringed. If the allegation concerns a registered trademark on counterfeit goods, the complaint and investigation must comply with the relevant provisions of the Trade Marks Act, including the applicable procedural safeguards.


Where copyright infringement is alleged, the complaint should clearly identify the original artistic or literary work, establish ownership or authority to act, and explain the alleged unauthorised reproduction or other infringing act.


Practitioners should avoid assuming that every logo, label, sticker, package or commercial product automatically supports a criminal copyright case. The legal character of the work and the statutory requirements must be assessed separately.


JUDGMENT / PRINCIPLE:


The Gujarat High Court allowed the petition and quashed the FIR dated 19 October 2022, together with the consequential proceedings against the petitioner.


The principal lesson is that trademark falsification and copyright infringement are distinct legal wrongs. Counterfeit commercial goods cannot automatically be treated as copyright-infringing works, and the authorities cannot bypass mandatory safeguards under the Trade Marks Act by framing a trademark dispute as a copyright offence.

bottom of page