Phantom Studios India Pvt. Ltd. v. JioStar India Pvt. Ltd.
A claimed co-ownership interest in a film does not automatically justify stopping a proposed sequel; the applicant must establish a prima facie legal basis for interim restraint.
Short Description About the Case
This dispute concerned the proposed film Queen Forever, associated with the 2014 film Queen. Phantom Studios India Pvt. Ltd. sought interim relief to stop further development and release of the proposed sequel, alleging that the project required its consent under an agreement concerning intellectual property rights in the original film.
Facts
Phantom Studios, a co-producer of the original Queen, claimed that it and JioStar India Pvt. Ltd. held equal shares in the intellectual property rights associated with the film. Phantom argued that the relevant co-production agreement extended to derivative works, including sequels, prequels, remakes and adaptations, and that Queen Forever could not proceed without its prior written consent. It also stated that it had sent notices to JioStar from April 2026 onwards objecting to the project.
Findings
The Bombay High Court declined to grant the requested interim injunction. The Court was not persuaded, at that stage, that Phantom Studios had established a sufficient basis to halt production and release of the proposed film. The reported dispute involved the interpretation of the parties’ contractual rights and the scope of any jointly held intellectual property in the original film and possible derivative works.
The refusal of interim relief does not finally determine every contractual or copyright issue between the parties. The matter remained a live dispute, and the reported decision concerned whether the film should be stopped at the interim stage.
Suggestion
Film co-production and licensing agreements should clearly define ownership shares, rights over sequels and remakes, approval requirements, derivative works, dispute resolution and the procedure for granting consent. A party seeking to stop a film project should produce the relevant agreements and identify the specific clause that gives it the right to prevent the proposed use.
Judgment / Principle
The Bombay High Court refused Phantom Studios’ request to stop production and release of Queen Forever at the interim stage, allowing the project to proceed for the time being. The order should not be described as a final declaration that Phantom has no rights in the original film or in any derivative work. It illustrates the need to establish a strong prima facie contractual and IP basis before seeking an injunction that could halt a film project.



