top of page

Sh. Shashi Bhushan & Ors. v. State of Delhi & Ors.

Oct 17
2 min read

Settlement with the affected IP owners may support quashing of criminal proceedings in an IP dispute, depending on the circumstances of the case.


Short Description About the Case


This case concerned criminal proceedings arising from allegations that the accused were stocking and selling counterfeit products bearing infringing trademarks and artistic works. The Delhi High Court considered whether the FIR and consequential proceedings could be quashed after the parties reached a settlement.


Facts


An FIR was registered at Sadar Bazar Police Station under Section 63 of the Copyright Act, 1957 and Sections 103 and 104 of the Trade Marks Act, 1999. The complainants were proprietors of certain trademarks and artistic works and alleged that the petitioners were dealing in unlicensed counterfeit goods. A charge sheet had been filed on 15 July 2024. During the proceedings, the petitioners and the IP rights owners entered into a compromise deed dated 27 July 2026, signed by the petitioners and the authorised representatives of the complainants.


Findings


The Court observed that, although the alleged offences were non-compoundable, the dispute was substantially connected with the commercial and civil rights of the IP proprietors, who were the aggrieved parties. Having considered the compromise and the principles governing the High Court’s inherent jurisdiction, the Court found no impediment to quashing the FIR in the circumstances presented.


Suggestion


For IP owners and businesses, a properly documented settlement may help resolve certain disputes, including criminal proceedings where the legal conditions permit. A compromise should clearly identify the relevant marks or works, the parties’ obligations, the scope of permitted use, and any restrictions on future dealings. Settlement does not automatically guarantee quashing in every IP prosecution.


Judgment / Principle


The Delhi High Court quashed FIR No. 0896/2022 and the proceedings arising from it, while directing the parties to remain bound by the compromise deed dated 27 July 2026. This was a fact-specific decision based on settlement; it should not be read as a general rule that all trademark or copyright offences can be privately settled.

bottom of page