top of page

Yesha Sant Designs Pvt. Ltd. v. Vidhi Singhal, Trading as Varie In & Ors.

Oct 17
2 min read

Where a permanent injunction has already been granted in the related appeal, the connected suit may be disposed of without re-adjudicating the same relief.


Short Description About the Case


This matter concerned a dispute over two shirt designs allegedly created by Yesha Sant Designs Pvt. Ltd. The later order of 25 September 2026 addressed the procedural position after a Division Bench had already made an interim injunction permanent against one defendant.


Facts


Yesha Sant Designs Pvt. Ltd. filed a commercial suit against Vidhi Singhal, trading as Varie In, and others. The dispute involved two shirt designs which the plaintiff claimed to have originally created and which were allegedly being manufactured or sold by the defendants. An ex parte ad-interim injunction had been passed on 24 March 2026. In the connected appeal, FAO(OS) (COMM) 110/2026, the Division Bench on 21 April 2026 made the injunction permanent against Defendant No. 1 and directed that a decree of permanent injunction be drawn. The appeal was disposed of on the basis of the statements and position recorded before the Court.


Findings


On 25 September 2026, the Single Judge was informed that the connected appeal had already resulted in a decree of permanent injunction against Defendant No. 1. In view of that development, the Court found that nothing further remained to be adjudicated in the present suit and disposed of it accordingly. The later order did not independently re-examine the substantive design-infringement allegations; it recorded the procedural consequence of the earlier appellate order.


Suggestion


In design and fashion-related IP disputes, preserve dated sketches, design files, samples, supplier communications, production records and evidence showing when a design was created and first disclosed or marketed. Where related proceedings concern the same designs and parties, counsel should keep the courts informed of orders passed in connected matters to avoid inconsistent or duplicative relief. Always distinguish an order disposing of a suit procedurally from a reasoned judgment after a full trial on originality or infringement.


Judgment / Principle


The Delhi High Court disposed of CS(COMM) 299/2026 on 25 September 2026 because the related appeal had already resulted in a permanent injunction decree against Defendant No. 1. The substantive permanent injunction had been made in the connected appeal on 21 April 2026. The September order should therefore be understood as a consequential disposal, not as a fresh finding that all defendants were liable for infringement.

bottom of page