Zee Learn Limited v. Sangam Lok Kalyan Shiksha Samiti
A licence to use a trademark under an educational alliance agreement does not automatically confer a continuing right to use the mark after termination of the agreement.
Short Description About the Case
This case concerned the unauthorised continuation of the “MOUNT LITERA” and “MOUNT LITERA ZEE SCHOOL” branding after an educational alliance agreement was allegedly terminated. The Bombay High Court considered interim protection of trademark and related intellectual property pending arbitration.
Facts
Zee Learn Limited had entered into an Academic Alliance Agreement, an Intellectual Property Rights Agreement and a Memorandum of Understanding with Sangam Lok Kalyan Shiksha Samiti on 12 November 2014. Under the arrangement, the respondent was given a limited, non-transferable licence to operate the Mount Litera Zee School Programme at its school in Rewa, Madhya Pradesh. Zee Learn alleged that the respondent failed to pay alliance fees of ₹8,46,357 for the academic years 2020–21 and 2021–22. The petitioner stated that it terminated the agreement under Clause 14.9 and that the respondent nevertheless continued to use its trademarks, name and logo. The respondent did not appear to contest the petition.
Findings
The Court held that the respondent’s right to use the marks arose from the agreements and was not an independent or unrestricted right. The petitioner had established a prima facie case for protection, and the balance of convenience favoured a limited injunction. The Court restrained use of the relevant marks and deceptively similar marks in a manner suggesting an ongoing association or affiliation with Zee Learn. It also ordered discovery and preservation of relevant documents. However, the Court did not grant every relief requested: appointment of a receiver, an escrow account and a bank guarantee were refused at that stage. The respondent was not prohibited from carrying on educational activities generally.
Suggestion
When drafting franchise, school-alliance, dealership or brand-licensing agreements, clearly specify the permitted use, territory, duration, fee obligations, termination process and post-termination duties. Upon termination, the IP owner should preserve evidence of continued branding and seek relief that is proportionate to the proven infringement. Monetary claims and trademark protection should be pleaded and supported separately where appropriate.
Judgment / Principle
The petition was partly allowed. Pending arbitration, the respondent was restrained from using the specified marks or deceptively similar marks to suggest an existing affiliation with the petitioner, unless otherwise authorised in writing or permitted by law. Relevant documents and evidence had to be disclosed and preserved. The Court’s approach shows that contractual termination can be important in determining whether continued trademark use remains authorised.



